Title: Pojken som förändrade världen – en kvalitativ innehållsanalys av bilderna på Alan Kurdi
Authors: Frida Bergstedt, Patricia Higson and Kajsa Kalméus
Subject: Undergraduate research paper in journalism studies, Dept. of journalism, media and communication, (JMG) Gothenburg University
Term: Spring 2016
Supervisor: Orla Vigsø
Purpose: Our main purpose was to understand what makes the photos of Alan Kurdi stand out and to investigate why Swedish newspapers published the photos. We wanted to understand how the photos were presented in Swedish newspapers and how the presentation affected the interpretation of them.
Method: Qualitative text analysis with a semiotic and rhetoric approach
Procedure: We analysed articles with photos of Alan Kurdi that were published in Swedish newspapers between the 3rd and 4th of September 2015.
Using theories about semiotics, rhetorics, newsworthiness and framing we analysed the material. The analysis was done in three steps: first we analysed the photos, then the text and lastly the text and photos combined.
Results: We found that the photos of Alan Kurdi stand out because of many reasons. They contain a lot of pathos and they probably generate similar emotions independent of the viewer’s background or cultural belonging. The framing of the photos in the newspapers strengthens their status and affects the way they are perceived. The framing gives them an iconic status and makes them metonymic. The photos represent something bigger than themselves, in this case the refugee crisis. We also found that the reason why newspapers chose to publish the photos despite the ethical dilemma of doing so might have been because of the public interest. Another reason to publish the photos was that the photos themselves are the news. It is the photos and the reaction to them that is the news in this case, not the event that led to Alan Kurdis death.
Key words: Alan Kurdi, bildjournalistik, nyhetsvärdering, appell, flyktingkris,
ikon, bildanalys, qualitative text analysis, metonymi, pressetik
Kategoriarkiv: Journalistikgranskning
Neutral ton eller mustigt språk?
This bachelor thesis is a study of two Swedish newspapers reporting about the swine flu in 2009. The study covers all articles written by the medical reporters of Dagens Nyheter and Svenska Dagbladet and published during 2009. The aim has been to compare the articles, using a method of text analysis called ECA, Etnographic Content Analysis, with regard to journalistic ideals of impartiality and a non-biased reporting. The study shows how the idealistic norms of journalism were set aside and that the reporting changed over time.
“Det är högt i tak, så länge man kryper”
The aim of this study is to examine how journalists in public service relate to objectivity and neutrality in their private social media. With respect to the requirements from the organization that the journalists should see themselves as a part of the organization and always try to maintain its credibility. We choose this theme primarily because the relevance of the subject. Social media is growing fast and there is a fine line between being personal and transparent and at the same time maintain the credibility of the organization by being objective and neutral. For journalists it can be a struggle to preserve a good balance between these requirements. We start our analysis primarily in theories about the ideal of objectivity and the social- and work identity. Out of these theories and our framing of the question we formed a survey that we sent to journalists at the six biggest Sveriges Radio and Sveriges Television newsrooms in Sweden. Our results show that the journalists tend to keep up with the ideal of objectivity and neutrality of the profession not only in duty, but also in their private life in social media. Partly because of the strict policies that public service have formulated for the journalists to follow and partly because of the results of our survey.
”Vem har skrivit den där?”
The purpose of this study is to investigate the shares of original material compared with the shares of rewrites and agency material in the Swedish printed national daily press. We want to see how it differs today from 20 years ago. We did this to see whether or not the shares of rewrites and news agency materials have increased over time. In addition to this the study examines what kind of materials are rewritten and bought from news agencies. Through a quantitative content analysis we have examined two trendsetting Swedish newspapers, Aftonbladet and Dagens Nyheter. We have examined a synthetic week for each of the two newspapers from both 1995 and 2015 and analyzed a total of 1646 news articles. Through our study we came, among other things, to the conclusions that the proportion of original material for the entire group is 55 percent today, which is the same level as in 1995. However, the composition of the material that isn’t produced by the newspapers own editorial staff has changed. The proportion of rewrites for the whole group has doubled from 6 to 12 percent, while the amount of news agency materials have dropped from 39 to 33 percent. We then proceeded with examining and comparing the evening and the morning newspapers and the differences then became more remarkable. The changes in general have become more prominent in Sweden’s leading tabloid, Aftonbladet, where the proportion of the internal news output has increased slightly. The most dramatic change, however, is regarding the proportion of rewrites that has more than doubled since 1995. These increases have occurred at the expense of material from news agencies. In Dagens Nyheter, Sweden’s largest morning newspaper, the trend has been slightly different. Here we have seen a constant amount of rewrites, but an increase of the material from news agencies at the expense of their internal news output. In this essays concluding part we use theories regarding tabloidization, digitalization and news evaluation to attempt to explain the changes we have identified.
Vad sa egentligen Tsipras?
The aim of this study was to investigate the news coverage of the Greek government-debt crisis which escalated during the summer of 2015. Our intention was to compare the four biggest nationwide newspapers Aftonbladet, Dagens Nyheter, Expressen and Svenska Dagbladet to see if their news coverage differs. Our results showed that their coverage was similar regarding what they covered, but the morning papers had a more in depth reporting. It also showed that the framing of the cause of the debt crisis were the same. However, our findings suggest that the morning papers had a more unbalanced reporting of the different actors.
Modellen av en människa
In our study, we have examined the presentation of gender in the Swedish programs Modellpojkar and Modellflickor. Reality documentary programs about swedish models, produced for Swedish Public Service. Our theoretical point of departure was gender theory found in the literature by Anja Hirdman and Raewyn Connell. They presented the term gender as a non-biological take on how we as men and women are expected to act in different situations in life. We have also compared the material with Maria Nikolajeva’s theories about stereotypes and other research material regarding gender presentation in media and commercials in general. We approached the material using qualitative method. To increase empirical validity we used both a textual analysis and a semiotical analysis. The textual analysis was used to examine the dialogue and how the models spoke about their private life, profession and body ideal et cetera. The semiotical analysis was used when watching five photo sessions in order to discover gender presentation in a visual context. The result showed us that gender is reproduced in terms of body ideal much due to current demands in model industry. At the same time, the boundaries of gender roles are somewhat being modified
”Vem får kalla Zlatan zigenare?”
This paper examines the media image of the Roma people, through the use of a quantitative content analysis. The analysis examines headlines and sub-headlines that contain the terms ”roma”, ”gypsy” or ”EU-migrants” (in swedish) and other grammatical forms of those words. The study was performed in a programme called SPSS, where I could choose different variables (which I called categories) that would describe the different headlines. It was possible to choose multiple categories for each headline and for each headline, those categories that best described the headline were chosen. The result of the study showed the overall portrayal of the Roma people in the two newspapers Dagens Nyheter and Aftonbladet, differences between the two newspapers, differences over time and how the use of the different terms looked like. The categories were ”demanding/complaining/mentally violated (roma)”, ”exotification”, ”poverty/misery”, ”racism”, ”discrimination”, ”everyday/common news”, problematic (roma), culture, vulnerable (roma), genocide, ”those people (we and the others)”, ”prejudice”, ”sensation”, ”roma that is given something”, good for the society (roma), ”feel good”, ”the roma registry”, ”begging”, ”deportation” and ”not clear”. The study and the analysis were based on the theories that are the base of this paper, with the power of the stereotypes, post colonialism, agenda setting and framing serving as the most important theories. The result of the analysis showed that the Roma people are mostly being portrayed in negative contexts, are being stereotyped or exotified, There is a difference over time, where exotification and ”we and the others” become less common the closer you get to present time. The coverage of vulnerable Roma, racism and discrimination rise to the roof the closer you get to present time. Not only the negative contexts become more common, but the Roma people are also being mentioned more in articles about common, everyday topics – where they are not only representatives of the Roma people as a group and where their actions are not made in to sensational things. The differences between the two papers are not exceptionally big, but in those areas where you can see a difference, it’s clear that Aftonbladet prioritises those news that are interesting from a market point of view, while Dagens Nyheter focuses more on what is important according to the norm.
Allt om förlossningen, amningen, kärleken och karriären
In this bachelor thesis in journalism studies we explore how the role of the mother is portrayed in the swedish magazine Mama. Mama is marketed towards women and is one of Sweden’s most widespread magazines in the segment of children and parents. Every issue of this magazine includes a profile story portraying a famous mother. We have analysed twelve of these stories. With the method of qualitative textual analysis we have studied four areas of interest: the relationship between the mother and her career, the relationship between the mother and her children, the relationship between the mother and her partner and what part the journalist takes in creating the discourse surrounding motherhood in these portraits, regarding in what way questions are asked and what hidden premise that may shine through in remarks made by the journalist. Our main results include that most of the women are portrayed as a supermother, who can handle a very successful career whilst still taking the main responsibility at home. We can also conclude the norm of the conjugal family is still strong in our material. Furthermore the study shows that the journalists who have written the profile stories often take the role of a friend and entrusted both towards the interviewee and the magazine readers.
Hålet i marken
In this study we have explored how Norrland and ”norrlandians” are portrayed in national public service news media. The method we have used is the qualitative textual analysis ECA (Ethnographic Content Analysis). This study has analysed Rapport’s cover of Northland’s mine in Kaunisvaara in Pajala, Norrbotten. Two main theories have been the focal point of this study: internal orientalism and news values. Our premise has been that ”norrlandians” and Norrland are subjected to stereotypical portrayals, and that these stereotypes are reproduced by the national news media. According to previous studies, this is the case in commercial national news media. Hence, this study has focused on wether this is also the case in national public service news media. To be able to map out if stereotypes are reproduced, we have applied four analytical themes, based on previous studies on stereotypes of ”norrlandians” and Norrland, on our material. These themes are: interpretative prerogative, how are ”norrlandians” portrayed?, how are other actors portrayed?, how is Pajala municipality portrayed? The main result of this study shows that some stereotypes of ”norrlandians” are reproduced, mainly that ”norrlandians” are passive, dependant on others and lack influence. The result also shows that some stereotypes are not reproduced, mainly the notion that Norrland is a place dominated by males.
